What are Convertible Notes in Startup Fundraising?

What is the Winding Up of a Company?

Winding up a company refers to the legal process of closing its operations permanently. It involves selling the company's assets, settling its debts and liabilities, and distributing any remaining surplus among shareholders according to their rights. Once the process is complete, the company is dissolved and ceases to exist as a legal entity. Winding up may be voluntary, initiated by members or creditors, or compulsory, ordered by a court.

The main reasons for winding up a company include:

• Ceasing the company's operations
• Collecting the company's assets
• Paying off the company's debts and liabilities
• Distributing any remaining assets to the members

The main reasons for winding up a company include:

• Inability to pay debts (insolvency)
• Completion of the purpose for which the company was formed
• Expiry of the period fixed for the duration of the company
• The passing of a special resolution by the members to wind up the company

Key Aspects of Winding Up of a Company

The winding up of a company involves several key aspects that need to be considered:

1.  Appointment of Liquidator

A liquidator is a person or entity responsible for managing the winding-up process of a company, including selling assets, settling liabilities, and distributing remaining funds to stakeholders. A liquidator is appointed to manage the winding up process. He is appointed by members or creditors in voluntary winding up or by the court in compulsory winding up. 

2.  Realisation of Assets

The liquidator takes possession of all the company's assets and realises them into cash. This may involve selling the company's property, plant and equipment, collecting debts from debtors, and recovering any unpaid capital from the contributors.

3.  Payment of Liabilities

The liquidator settles all the company's liabilities, including debts owed to creditors, outstanding taxes and employee dues. The order of priority for payment is fixed by law, with secured creditors being paid first, followed by unsecured creditors and members.

4. Distribution of Surplus

After settling all the liabilities, surplus assets are distributed among the members in proportion to their shareholding. Preference shareholders are paid first, including any arrears, as per their rights. Once their claims are fully settled, the remaining surplus is allocated to equity shareholders in proportion to their shareholding. This process adheres to the company’s articles and legal requirements, ensuring an equitable distribution.

5. Dissolution of Company

Once the winding up process is complete, the liquidator submits a final report to the Tribunal or the ROC. The Tribunal then orders the dissolution of the company, and its name is struck off from the register of companies.

Types of Winding Up

There are three main modes of winding up of a company under the Companies Act 2013:

1. Compulsory Winding Up of a Company (By the Tribunal)
2. Voluntary Winding Up of a Company

a) Members' Voluntary Winding Up

b) Creditors' Voluntary Winding Up

3. Winding Up Subject to the Supervision of the Tribunal

Let us discuss each of these types in detail.

1. Compulsory Winding Up (By the Court)

Compulsory winding up of a company is when a company is wound up by an order of a court or tribunal. This is also known as "winding up by the court". The court may order a company to be wound up on various grounds specified in Section 433 of the Companies Act, 1956 (now governed by Chapter XX of the Companies Act, 2013).

Compulsory winding up of a company is initiated by a petition filed before the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) by:

• The company itself
• The company's creditors
• The company's contributors
• The Registrar of Companies
• Any person authorised by the Central Government

The grounds for compulsory winding up include:

• Inability to pay debts
• Acting against the sovereignty and integrity of India
• Conducting affairs in a fraudulent manner
• Failure to file financial statements or annual returns for five consecutive years
• The Tribunal is of the opinion that it is just and equitable to wind up the company

If the NCLT is satisfied that a prima facie case for winding up is made out, it admits the petition, appoints an official liquidator and makes an order for winding up.

2. Voluntary winding up of a company

Voluntary winding up is when a company is wound up by its members or creditors without the intervention of a court or tribunal. Voluntary winding up is initiated by the company itself by passing a special resolution in a general meeting. There are two types of voluntary winding up:

1. Members' Voluntary Winding Up

This occurs when the company is solvent and can pay its debts in full. A declaration of solvency is made by a majority of the directors, stating that they have made an inquiry into the company's affairs and believe that the company has no debts or will be able to pay its debts in full within three years from the commencement of the winding up.

2.  Creditors' Voluntary Winding Up: 

This occurs when the company is insolvent and unable to pay its debts in full. No declaration of solvency is made in this case. The creditors play a greater role in this type of winding up compared to a members' voluntary winding up.

In a voluntary winding up, the company appoints a liquidator in a general meeting to conduct the winding up proceedings.

3. Winding Up Subject to the Supervision of the Court

A voluntary winding up (whether members' or creditors') may be converted into a winding up by the Tribunal if the Tribunal is of the opinion that the company's affairs are being conducted in a manner prejudicial to the interests of the public or the company.

In such cases, the Tribunal may order that the voluntary winding up shall continue but subject to the supervision of the Tribunal. The Tribunal may appoint an additional liquidator to conduct the winding up along with the liquidator appointed by the company.

Winding Up a Company Process

The procedure for winding up of a company in India depends on the mode of winding up. Here is a step-by-step procedure for compulsory winding up of a company in India and voluntary winding up:

The process of winding up of a company in India is complex and involves several legal formalities. It is advisable to seek the assistance of a professional (such as a company secretary or a lawyer) to ensure compliance with all the requirements.

Example of Winding up of a Company

One notable example of the winding up of a company in India is the case of Kingfisher Airlines Limited. Kingfisher Airlines was a prominent Indian airline that ceased operations in 2012 due to financial difficulties and mounting debts.

In 2016, the Karnataka High Court ordered the winding up of the company on a petition filed by the Airports Authority of India, which was one of the company's creditors. The court appointed an Official Liquidator to take charge of the company's assets and manage the winding up process.

The liquidator faced several challenges in the winding up process, including the recovery of dues from the company's debtors and the sale of its assets. The company had a fleet of aircraft and other assets, which had to be valued and sold to pay off the creditors.

One of the major issues in the winding up of Kingfisher Airlines was the recovery of dues from its promoter, Vijay Mallya. Mallya had given personal guarantees for some of the loans taken by the company, and the creditors sought to recover these dues from him. However, Mallya fled to the UK, and the Indian authorities have been trying to extradite him to face charges of fraud and money laundering.

The winding up process of Kingfisher Airlines is still ongoing, and the liquidator is working to realise the company's assets and settle its liabilities. The case highlights the challenges involved in the winding up of a large and complex company with multiple stakeholders and legal issues.

The Kingfisher Airlines case also underscores the importance of timely action by creditors in the event of default by a company. Many of the company's creditors, including banks and airports, had allowed the debts to accumulate for several years before initiating legal action. This delay made it more difficult to recover the dues and increased the losses for the creditors.

In conclusion, the winding up of Kingfisher Airlines is a cautionary tale for companies and creditors alike. It highlights the need for effective risk management, timely action in case of default, and the importance of following due process in the winding-up of a company.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the winding up is a legal process of  liquidating a company's assets, settling of liabilities and distributing surplus to its members. It is a complex process that requires careful planning and execution, and the guidance of professional advisors. 

There are three modes in winding up under companies act 2013: compulsory winding up by the Tribunal, voluntary winding up by the members or creditors and winding up under the Tribunal's supervision. 

These modes of winding up have specific requirements and procedures. Proper planning and professional guidance can help minimise the impact on stakeholders like creditors, employees and members, ensuring a smoother and compliant winding-up process.

Frequently Asked Questions

Startup Definition as per the Startup India Action Plan

According to the Startup India Action Plan, a startup is defined as:

• An entity that is less than five years old from the date of incorporation or registration.
• Has a turnover not exceeding INR 25 crore in any financial year.
• Is working toward innovation, development, or improvement of products, processes, or services; or has a scalable business model with a high potential for employment generation or wealth creation.

Additionally, the entity must not be formed by splitting up or reconstructing an existing business.

Startups can access tax benefits only after certification from the Inter-Ministerial Board (IMB), which examines the business model, innovation, and scalability before granting approval.

Eligibility for Startup India

To qualify under the Startup India scheme, a business must meet the following eligibility conditions:

Age of the Company:

The entity must be less than 10 years old from the date of incorporation or registration.

Type of Entity:

It should be registered as a Pvt. Ltd. Company, Partnership Firm, or Limited Liability Partnership (LLP).

Turnover Limit:

The startup’s annual turnover must not exceed INR 100 crore in any financial year since incorporation.

Innovation Focus:

The startup should aim to develop innovative products, processes, or services, or have a scalable business model with high job creation or wealth generation potential.

Non-Reconstruction Clause:

The startup must not be formed by restructuring or splitting up an existing business.

Startups Eligible for Startup India Tax Exemptions & Incentives

To qualify, startups must:

• Be recognised under DPIIT (Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade).
• Be involved in innovating or improving existing products, services, or processes.
• Be supported or funded by:
  
  • Recognised incubators or government schemes, or
  • SEBI-registered venture capital funds, or
  • Hold granted patents that support innovation.

Startups that lack innovative value, engage in routine business models, or do not contribute to technological advancement are not eligible for these tax incentives.

Obtaining Startup Tax Exemption under the Startup India Initiative

To avail tax exemptions, startups must go through a formal approval and verification process by the Inter-Ministerial Board (IMB) constituted by the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT) to qualify for tax exemptions.

Steps to Obtain Startup Tax Exemption:

1. Get DPIIT Recognition:

Before anything else, your entity must be a DPIIT-recognised startup. This involves registering on the Startup India portal and certifying your eligibility (age, turnover, entity type, etc.).

2. Prepare Your Application & Documents:

This is the most crucial step. The IMB needs to be convinced of your startup's genuine innovation. Your application must be supported by a detailed set of documents, which typically includes:

• Business Documents: Your Memorandum of Association (MoA) or LLP Deed.
• Financials: Audited annual accounts and Income Tax Returns (ITRs) for the last three financial years (or since incorporation, if newer).
• The "Innovation" Proof (Pitch Deck / Video): A presentation and/or a short video (under 2-5 minutes) that clearly explains:
  
  • What your product/service is.
  • What new problem it solves.
  • How it is innovative (e.g., a new technology, a disruptive process, or a significant improvement on an existing solution).
  • Your business model and scalability.
• Shareholding Information: Details of your current shareholding pattern.
• CA Certificate: A certificate from a Chartered Accountant verifying that your startup has not been formed by splitting up or reconstructing an existing business.

3. Submit the Application:

The application for tax exemption (Form 80-IAC) is also filed through the Startup India portal. You will upload all your prepared documents and fill in the required fields.

4. IMB Verification:

The IMB board (which includes members from DPIIT, Department of Biotechnology, etc.) will formally review your application. Their entire focus is to determine if your startup is "working towards innovation, development or improvement of products or processes or services" and is not just a conventional business.

5. Receive Certification:

If the IMB is satisfied, you will be granted the certificate of eligibility. You can then use this certificate to claim the 100% tax deduction when filing your Income Tax Returns (ITR) for any three consecutive years within your first ten years.

‍

Common Mistakes: Why IMB Applications Get Rejected

Many startups get DPIIT recognition but fail the IMB certification. Be careful to avoid these common pitfalls:

• Insufficient Proof of Innovation: This is the #1 reason for rejection. Simply having a new website or app is not enough. You must prove you are solving a problem in a new way, have a new technology, or are creating a unique, scalable process.
• Incomplete or Vague Pitch Deck: If the board cannot understand what your business does or why it's innovative within a few minutes, your application will be rejected or deferred.
• Incorrect Documents: Submitting unsigned financials, a missing CA certificate, or an incomplete MoA will lead to rejection on technical grounds.
• Reconstruction of an Old Business: The IMB is strict about this. If your "startup" is just an old business (e.g., a consultancy or services firm) repackaged under a new name to avoid taxes, it will be rejected.
• Lack of Scalability: The IMB also looks for businesses with high potential for wealth creation or employment generation. A small lifestyle business, even if innovative, may not qualify.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Format of a Partnership Deed

{{scroll-image}}

The format of a partnership deed may vary based on the specific requirements of the partners and the nature of the business. However, a typical partnership deed includes the following essential elements:

• Name of the Partnership:
  The official business name under which the partnership operates is stated, along with the physical address where the primary business activities occur. This section also highlights the duration of the partnership firm alongside the date of the commencement.
• Details of the Partners:
  This section includes the full name, address, and relevant particulars of the Individuals participating in the Partnership.
• Purpose:
  Here, the nature and scope of the business activities conducted by the partnership is clearly stated. The firm shall have the power to fulfill the objectives of thecompany and conduct any such lawful business activities.
• Capital Contribution:
  The total capital of the firm and the individual share contributed by each partner are to be mentioned here. The contribution can be in cash, goods, or property on agreed values.
• Profit and Loss Sharing:
  ‍It clearly articulates the agreed-upon ratio or percentage in which profits and losses will be distributed among the partners.
• Financial Decisions:
  It includes information such as the partners' salary and commission, permissive drawings from the firm for each partner, the interest payable to the firm on these drawings, partnership loans, and other relevant details.
• Admission and Retirement of Partners:
  ‍This part outlines the criteria and process for admitting new partners into the business. Similarly, it details the procedures for the retirement or withdrawal of existing partners.
• Dispute Resolution:
  Procedures for resolving disputes among partners are established. This may include mechanisms for mediation or arbitration to address conflicts and maintain a harmonious partnership.
• Dissolution:
  It states the conditions and procedures for the dissolution of the partnership which highlights the distribution of assets, settlement of liabilities, and the overall process of winding up the business.
• Witnesses and Signatures:
  The partnership deed is formally executed with the signatures of all partners, and done in the presence of witnesses.

How to draft a Partnership Deed?

A partnership deed can be a verbal or written agreement outlining the rights, responsibilities, profit-sharing, and other obligations of the partners.

While it can be recorded verbally, it is highly advisable to formalize a written partnership deed with the Registrar of Firms as it aids in resolving potential disputes. It also proves beneficial for tax purposes and ensures the formal registration of the partnership firm.

• The Partnership Deed, formulated by the partners, must be executed on stamp paper with a minimum value of Rs. 200, as per the Indian Stamp Act.
• Each partner should retain a copy of the partnership deed for future reference.
• Once stamped, the Partnership deed is attached with the application to the Registrar of Firms for formal registration and legal validation.

As per the Partnership Act, Registration of Partnership Firms is optional, but if you still choose to register your firm-

The application should be accompanied by essential documents, including a duly filled affidavit, a certified true copy of the Partnership Deed, and proof of ownership or a rental/lease agreement for the main business location.

Validity of the Partnership Deed

The validity of the firm is mentioned in the deed, whether it's for a limited period, for a specific project or for an unlimited period.

Note: A partnership deed that has been notarized alone does not hold legal validity in the event of legal disputes. However, if the partnership firm is formally registered with RoF, the partnership deed will be recognized as having legal standing.

Fees for the Partnership Deed in India

The Partnership Deed must be executed on a stamp paper with a minimum value of Rs. 200, as per the Indian Stamp Act.

However, Partnership registration fees vary among states due to different compliance requirements and stamp duty rates. The cost for registering a Partnership Firm ranges from Rs. 500 to Rs. 3000.

Note: Stamp duty is calculated based on partner contributions and follows state-specific regulations.

Alterations in the Partnership Deed

Partners have the flexibility to modify, alter, or change the partnership deed through mutual agreement. All partners are required to sign the amended deed.

Subsequently, the modified partnership deed should be registered at the Sub-Registrar's office, where the original deed was registered. Additionally, it is necessary to submit the modified deed to the Registrar of Firms for record-keeping purposes.

{{business-cta}}